Sunday, December 12, 2010

Righteousness: in secret or before others?

An issue that has concerned me a few times lately is when it is appropriate to show one's good deeds before others. If someone accuses me of selfishness, should I share what I have done for the poor? If someone hints that I do not love my wife, should I tell how I have loved her lately? These issues can be treacherous with a sin nature like ours.

There are two key passages regarding the practice of righteousness before others, and they seem to contradict each other!

The first is Matthew 5:16, In the same way, let your light shine before others, so that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father who is in heaven.

The second is Matthew 6:1-18, particularly verse 1, Beware of practicing your righteousness before other people in order to be seen by them, for then you will have no reward from your Father who is in heaven..

Taken at face value, these statements of Jesus are in direct opposition to each other. Should we let others "see [our] good works" or does that displease God and forfeit our heavenly reward? To answer that question, let's look at the essential meanings of the two passages.

In Matthew 5:13-16, Jesus speaks of the disciples' role in the world as "salt" and "light." What is the meaning of these two metaphors? Salt is a preservative: disciples are to slow the corruption of the world. Light, on the other hand, represents God's exposition of sin and call to moral purity (1 John). Thus, when you let others see your light, or your works, it is to show them to moral purity of God ("give glory to your Father"). The Apostle Peter clarifies this purpose in 1 Peter 2:12, Keep your conduct among the Gentiles honorable, so that when they speak against you as evildoers, they may see your good deeds and glorify God on the day of visitation.

In Matthew 6:1-18, on the other hand, Jesus explores three topics—giving to the needy, prayer, and fasting—that were apparently issues in His day. From His words we see that the "hypocrites" did these things in the sight of others and "received [their] reward" this way. The reward was the approval of other Jews who saw these hypocrites as super-holy.

Jesus here warns that our reward comes from God, who sees "in secret," that is, He sees not only our public front but our private lives as well. Jesus therefore calls us to pay less attention to the good we do in public and more that that which we do in private. What a sad life it would be to pray only in public and never enjoy personal times of prayer with God.

Taking the two key passages together, the issue is ultimately—like so much in Scripture—a matter of the heart. The attitude of the heart in the first passage is to show God's righteousness; that attitude in the second is to show your own. Therefore, whenever we think of doing a righteous act before others, we must examine ourselves to see whose glory we are seeking: ours or God's. What are some ways we can do this?

One test I hear in church a while ago regarded thanks. The pastor said that in true humility one should be willing to serve without a chance of being told, "thank you." This will show that you are seeking no reward from man.

Another similar test I can think of is who you are talking to. If you are about to tell someone of a righteous act you committed, what will his response be? If the response would be some congratulations to you, then your intentions are most likely selfish. If the resopnse would be more praise (or, in some cases, less enmity) towards God, then go for it! That is exactly what Jesus would want you to do.

Well, this post has been straightforward, but I hope it will be useful to you all. May God give you good discernment and pure intentions in your public righteousness! Praise God for our redemption.

5 comments:

Dream said...

Cool post! Those are some useful tests. Thank you for writing.

James Hogan said...

Very, very nice. Thanks for the helpful(and Biblical!!) thoughts.

Kristie said...

Good thoughts! This is sometimes a difficult topic to sift through.
Another side of this issue is the fear we sometimes have of seeming "self-righteous"-- too righteous in the eyes of our peers. This is another dangerous trap, as if we become to worried about this, we may choose not to act righteously in the eyes of God for fear of the eyes of our peers.
I think the tests you put forth are also helpful in responding to this dilemma.
Ultimately, the ideal would be to live our lives as if no one but God is watching, and hold out hope that others may be inspired by what they see.

Kristie said...

Another way of thinking is that we can act righteously by opening the way for others to be righteous, either by inviting others to join us or by starting charitable (or whatever other kind) of organizations (large or small) that other people can contribute to.

This is something that has a strong history with the Quakers. If a quaker feels led to begin such a project or undertaking, they are encouraged to consult with others from their meeting (aka church) to find "clearness" in their intentions. I think this is an important way a religious community can together understand its paths to righteousness.

But this does not have to be some big production or the start of a new movement. It can be as simple as inviting a friend to contribute to your church's bake sale. Your simple righteous act becomes the work of others as well.

Unknown said...

Thanks for the thoughts, Kristie. I agree--helping others in righteousness is surely honored in God's sight.